• Follow us


The Legitimate Critique of Minimalism - The Good Men Project

Some of you may have read this internet article on a critique of Minimalism.  It’s worth the read, but if you don’t want to, here is my summary.  The point is that only those who can afford to be minimalists can do so voluntarily.

A second related point of the article is that we tend to turn everything, even minimalism, into a product to buy. There are additional cheap shots at décor and design, as well as straw man arguments of people who shop at IKEA.

First, the points I agree on, then my critique of the critique.  OK.  I’d say the author has a valid point, though it tends to be a bit whiny for my taste.  I mean it’s ok for me to whine, but not others.

There is validity to a choice to pursue a more minimalist lifestyle is one that those who have can choose.  If you are poor, then you are already a minimalist, and that stinks.  Only rich white guys get the joy and freedom of simplicity.

So goes the argument.  There is some merit to this argument.

For me personally, I have a comfortable middle-class life, with a respectable income.  Actually, by global standards, it’s outrageously excessive.  My friends in Honduras make less than 10% of what I make in a year.

My comfortable North American US lifestyle affords me many choices that others don’t have.  I can choose to live a life where I spend less on junk, save more for the future and be outrageously generous.  Yes, I’m also white, and not only male, but I’m 6’7”

All these things place me in a position of great power in this society.  With that comes the freedom of choice.  Not everyone has that freedom – I get that.

The other valid point is the commodification of, well just about everything in our society, even minimalism.  Yes, this is true.  In the words of Andrew Carnegie, “The business of America is business.” (I think it was Carnegie maybe Rockefeller)

We are a consumer-driven culture.  The people who have championed minimalism have written books, gone on tours, made films.  Those activities are the same activities of everything from U2 rock tours to the latest business seminar or product.  In addition, those of us who are moving along this minimalism path have purchased books, subscribed to Netflix to watch a documentary.

So, yes, even minimalism can be co-opted by the very economic cultural bubble it is challenging.

Now let’s push back on this article as well as other patterns I’m observing.

The clearest point I want to make is best captured in the phrase, “no good deed goes unpunished.”  Increasingly, the chronic anxiety in our culture is fighting to grab those people and movements attempting to make change and pull them back into the homeostasis of the status quo.  The implication of these critiques is a DE legitimization of the whole endeavor.

We are trending in a direction that says the contributions of Woodrow Wilson, Thomas Jefferson or Martin Luther are discredited because of their flaws.  Do we toss out the Reformation because Luther was clearly anti-Semitic?  (Yes, I intentionally chose three white men to make this point, because I recognize how the merits of my argument could be harder to hear if I had chosen others).

Was Luther also probably a really unpleasant person around the dinner table? Yes.  Was Jefferson a slave owner? Yes.  Did Woodrow Wilson have segregationist views? Yes.  Does that mean they did not also make valuable contributions to further society?

One of our theological convictions in the Lutheran expression of Christianity is that we are both saint & sinner simultaneously.  I’m endeavoring to write an essay here that is intended to move the conversation along in a positive manner.  Am I also a little defensive of the critique of something that is positively impacting my life? You bet.  Both are true.

A second point that needs to be acknowledged is around the topic of minimalism and the wealthy.  Is minimalism for the wealthy?  Yes.

Yes, it is.  We are the ones that most need minimalism.  We in the consumptive US North American are the greatest abusers of greed and its environmental impact.  It’s economic destabilization.  Mostly, of it’s spiritual vacuity.  Was Sigmund Freud right when he wrote his book, “Civilization and it’s Discontents”?  Are we miserable despite having achieved a standard of living that exceeds all of human civilization?

So yes, Minimalism is a legitimate response for those of us in the US Middle Class and Up?  We are the ones who need to hear the message.  My friends in Honduras, they don’t need minimalism –they need economic justice.  You and I buying T-Shirts that are made in San Pedro Sula are not helping them, we are actually empowering an abusive borderline slave labor system in that country.

Finally, a reminder that minimalism is not one thing.  It is not a duality, where you are in or out.  It’s more helpful to think of it as a spectrum.

Yes, some minimalists own 333 things, others don’t own a house and travel the world with only 51 things.  But, others live in Arizona suburbs, with spouses and kids that are not so minimal.  Still others home school their child, and ride a bike everywhere they go in Colorado, including grocery shopping.

I’m on a minimalist journey.  I’m spending less, giving more and saving more.  Do I own a car? Yes.  But, my next one won’t be a brand new, and I’ll try to take the one I have as far as it goes.

Do I own a house?  Well, the bank and I do, and I’m working a plan to rid the bank portion quickly. Do I love books?  Yes, but now I use the local library system for about 90% of those books.  I haven’t bought new clothes since last November, and my goal is to make it through a year before I do so again, and even then what do I need vs want.  How many shirts does a guy need?  My wife and I have decreased our restaurant meals by 80% this year.  We are eating in, enjoying cooking, shopping for local food more.

Why am I doing this?  What’s the real purpose behind it?

Is it because I’m in need of a sense of being morally superior to some people?  Am I looking to justify my judgmental side?  Do I just need another project?  Perhaps those play into this new endeavor.  After all, I like you am a mixed bag of angels and devils.

I’d like to think that my motivations also include a desire to live more consistently into my Christian faith.  Living more simply does give me a clear sense of integrity about being a follower of Jesus.  Richard Foster’s Freedom of Simplicity has helped me here.  In addition, I’m moving along the minimalism path because I am reaching a point in life, at six decades, where I am fatigued of the whole ‘stuff’ thing.

There is just too much crap in life these days.  It’s on TV, it’s on You Tube, it’s in stores.  It’s plastic, it’s cheap and it’s just all clutter.  Is that a midlife thing?  Could be.  Then there is a desire to learn the art of discipline.  I’m finding there is real value in discipline.  When I’m melancholic, and want to buy something, I’m asking new questions.

What’s this about inside me?  What void am I filling?  Why not just live with the melancholy rather than trying to push it away?

Finally, I’m in a reordering of my priorities in life.  What gives me deep pleasure?  It’s increasingly some simple things.  A meal with friends, a bike ride, mowing the lawn or even sitting down to write an essay on minimalism.

Originally Published on Bishop on a Bike

Read More

Leave A Comment

More News


HyperJuice's 130W USB-C Battery might be the perfect New! 2019-05-20 16:14:09You will never ever have to hunt for a power socket if you're equipped with one of HyperJuice's new 130W batteries. With 27000mAh of battery ca

Nike's auto-lacing Adapt BB gets a familiar new New! 2019-05-20 05:59:58For those who dream of owning an actual Air Mag with real power laces can now get their hands on the next best thing. Nike is calling the colorway "W

Bentley captures its 100-year history in a massive, 2019-05-17 14:47:56Bentley's last 100 years is quite a story and to capture it properly, the prestigious automaker teamed up with Opus to tell the story in an absolutel

Blancpain reissues one of its rarest watches, the 2019-05-17 14:15:03Alongside the Fifty Fathoms Barakuda, Blancpain is also reissuing what's considered to be one of their rarest and most valuable models, the Air Comma

Leica celebrates 100 years of Bauhaus with a 2019-05-17 13:45:35Whether you're a Leica collector or simply a fan of everything Bauhaus-related, you'll definitely want one of these new Leica CL "100 years of bauh

Blancpain reissues the Fifty Fathoms Barakuda from the 2019-05-17 05:40:02Blancpain fans looking for a classic Fifty Fathoms design in a smaller case will be excited to know that the company is reissuing the Barakuda model i

Omega turns the Seamaster into an elegant Worldtimer 2019-05-17 05:22:08The Omega Seamaster is going global with a new limited edition GMT Worldtimer model that's based on the Aqua Terra 150M. The 43mm watch features a su

Omega marks 50 years of the Apollo 11 2019-05-17 04:50:40The first watch to make its way onto the lunar surface is celebrating 50 years of the Apollo 11 moon landing with a special edition of the Omega Speed

BMW celebrates 35 years of the M5 2019-05-16 20:13:00This year marks the 35th anniversary of one of the most beloved high-performance BMWs, the M5. The 2020 model is the most powerful version of the M5 e

Jaeger-LeCoultre introduces the Master Grande Tradition Répétition Minutes 2019-05-16 19:46:55Jaeger-LeCoultre has a deep history of building innovative chiming watches and the company considers it to be at the very foundation of their mec

Bring a Trailer launches its Plus and White 2019-05-16 18:42:37Bring a Trailer has definitely made a big impact on vintage car sales and now the company aims to help sellers perfect their listings with two new pre

Rapha's Explore Waterproof Rear Pack is a must-have 2019-05-16 18:18:34When you're riding long distances, a solid piece of bike luggage is always a good call. The only problem is that some bags tend to affect the balance

The Good Men Project

Three Lessons Learned While Transitioning from an Executive New! 2019-05-20 16:30:46Be Courageous, get creative, and make the commitment. The post Three Lessons Learned While Transitioning from an Executive to an Entrepreneur appeare

Hear a Pretty Touching Tale in ‘Planet Earth New! 2019-05-20 16:00:17Learn all about Nova in ‘Planet Earth is Blue’ There are some really good books out there right now. I have been lucky to read many of the

Giving Our Kids Power to Deal New! 2019-05-20 15:30:52The battle against Nature Deficit Disorder. The post Giving Our Kids Power to Deal appeared first on The Good Men Project.

Coming Out To Parents in 1975 New! 2019-05-20 15:00:35“You’re Our Son. We Love You. Be Home By Midnight.” The post Coming Out To Parents in 1975 appeared first on The Good Men Project.

Do Something Really Old School – Write Your New! 2019-05-20 14:30:33Writing my son has made our relationship stronger. Writing him has made us both better men. The post Do Something Really Old School – Write You

Overcoming Fear (Or, Life is Like a Rollercoaster) New! 2019-05-20 14:00:47How can you step outside of your comfort zone in order to honor your calling and purpose? The post Overcoming Fear (Or, Life is Like a Rollercoaster)

Enter, Father New! 2019-05-20 13:30:08The Magical Moment Checking in at the triage ward of the Women and Children’s hospital is a moment of reckoning for a man. It means you’ve

Unless You Are a Toddler, You Should Not New! 2019-05-20 13:00:21Time to grow up. The post Unless You Are a Toddler, You Should Not Need Anyone’s Undivided Attention appeared first on The Good Men Project.

Finding Yourself After Divorce (and Other Trauma) New! 2019-05-20 12:30:47There’s no shortcut to reclaiming your life. The post Finding Yourself After Divorce (and Other Trauma) appeared first on The Good Men Project.

What Turns Men On? New! 2019-05-20 12:00:34I will get straight to the point and be a bit open and blunt about it. The post What Turns Men On? appeared first on The Good Men Project.

No One Can Save You New! 2019-05-20 11:30:49Why we're all our own experts. The post No One Can Save You appeared first on The Good Men Project.

Survival Traits of Resilient, Successful People New! 2019-05-20 11:00:02Develop Strategies that Make you Better in the Workplace, in Relationships, and In Your Daily Life The post Survival Traits of Resilient, Successful P


This Stunning Outdoor Resort Is the Ultimate Stargazer's New! 2019-05-20 16:18:06A luxurious new South American resort offers stargazers the ultimate celestial paradise. Settled nearly 12,000 feet above sea level on the arid grou

Here Are All the Best Memes From 'Game New! 2019-05-20 14:57:30One good thing about Game of Thrones: It's ardent, social media-loving fanbase can make some wickedly funny memes. Especially when the show is p

Season 3 'Westworld' Trailer Introduces Aaron Paul to New! 2019-05-20 14:31:26Just because Game of Thrones is finally finished, doesn’t mean that HBO has stopped betting big on prestige dramas. Assuming that the pay cable

Rapper Future Gave His 5-Year-Old Son a Gold New! 2019-05-20 13:27:36Hip-hop heavyweight Future gifted his son, Future Zahir Wilburn, one swanky accessory for his 5th birthday.  The Atlanta-bred rapper, who he

The Bentley Bentayga Bengala Is Half Luxury SUV, New! 2019-05-20 11:23:19The ultra-posh Bentley Bentayga is getting a gritty makeover fit for a military tank.  Bengala Automotive Design, a Spanish design house previous

Someone Left a Water Bottle in the 'Game New! 2019-05-20 10:30:02It was one of the last big moments in Game of Thrones. Most surviving major characters were gathered listening to Peter Dinklage's Tyrion Lannister e

Moët & Chandon's Cellar Master On Why The New! 2019-05-20 08:00:00Champagne, that most aristocratic of libations, is at crossroads.  Exports have now overtaken domestic consumption of the French sparkling wine t

Bella Hadid Kissed a Female Robot in a 2019-05-19 16:01:17Bella Hadid is heterosexual, therefore she's not allowed to kiss women. Even robots who look like women. Even virtual reality robots that don't have

Deontay Wilder Ends Dominic Breazeale Feud With Vicious 2019-05-19 16:00:18Well, that was quick. Deontay Wilder made very short work of Dominic Breazeale Saturday night at Barclays Center in Brooklyn. The bad blood between th

Joe Rogan Responds To His Eerily Accurate AI-Generated 2019-05-19 12:44:37The future is here, and it's scaring the hell out of podcaster extraordinaire and MMA commentator Joe Rogan. As it should, since someone made an AI p

Viral Video Shows Arnold Schwarzenegger Drop-Kicked While Greeting 2019-05-18 16:03:57A crazed man attacked Arnold Schwarzenegger with a flying double dropkick to his back, sending The Terminator tumbling at a sports event for scho

2019 Ferrari 488 Pista Drive Review: A Supercar 2019-05-18 07:00:00The launch of any new Ferrari is always an epic automotive event. The supercar's signature red color scheme, iconic Prancing Horse branding

Real Men Real Style

Punch Procrastination In The Face! 5 FAIL PROOF 2019-05-11 07:55:19The post Punch Procrastination In The Face! 5 FAIL PROOF Steps To Get S*** Done! appeared first on Real Men Real Style. Related posts:Harvey Specter

Best Men’s Colognes: 10 AMAZING Summer Fragrances 2019-05-09 07:55:42The post Best Men’s Colognes: 10 AMAZING Summer Fragrances appeared first on Real Men Real Style. Related posts:5 NEWBIE Style Rules To Break A

10 Items EVERY Guy Needs MORE Of To 2019-05-07 07:55:01The post 10 Items EVERY Guy Needs MORE Of To Be Successful (Own Multiples & Level-Up Your Style) appeared first on Real Men Real Style. Related p

20 Signs You Care TOO Much About Style 2019-05-05 08:00:31The post 20 Signs You Care TOO Much About Style appeared first on Real Men Real Style. Related posts:How To Reset A Bad Day | 5 Tips To Recover From

How To Dress In Your 20s (Style Tips 2019-05-04 07:55:50The post How To Dress In Your 20s (Style Tips For Men) appeared first on Real Men Real Style. Related posts:Men’s Style Upgrade | Collar Stays

10 Mistakes Older Guys Make Trying To Look 2019-05-02 07:55:46The post 10 Mistakes Older Guys Make Trying To Look Young appeared first on Real Men Real Style. Related posts:First 5 Shoes Every Man NEEDS | The Be

7 Minimalist Men’s Wardrobe Essentials & How To 2019-04-30 07:55:16The post 7 Minimalist Men’s Wardrobe Essentials & How To Buy appeared first on Real Men Real Style. Related posts:First 5 Shoes Every Man N

A Guide To Social Dress Codes For Men 2019-04-28 08:00:22The post A Guide To Social Dress Codes For Men (Clothing Etiquette Rules) appeared first on Real Men Real Style. Related posts:How To Sew On A Button

7 Tricks To Save $100 (Or More!) When 2019-04-27 07:55:18The post 7 Tricks To Save $100 (Or More!) When Buying Luxury Shoes appeared first on Real Men Real Style. Related posts:Italian vs American Dress Sho

10 Watch Styles Every Man Should Know 2019-04-25 07:55:04The post 10 Watch Styles Every Man Should Know appeared first on Real Men Real Style. Related posts:10 Simple Men’s Style Upgrades – Quic

10 Scientifically Proven Ways To Be More Attractive 2019-04-23 07:55:37The post 10 Scientifically Proven Ways To Be More Attractive appeared first on Real Men Real Style. Related posts:Seduce With Style | Sexiest Clothin

10 Famous Clothing Logos With Hidden Meaning 2019-04-21 07:55:22The post 10 Famous Clothing Logos With Hidden Meaning appeared first on Real Men Real Style. Related posts:Sherpa Jacket How To Tie The Eldredge Kno


Suitsupply Opens First Store in Paris 2019-05-10 12:15:46All proceeds from sales made on the store's opening day went to the Notre-Dame restoration fund.

Rose in Good Faith Seeks to Diversify Through 2019-05-10 11:48:57The Los Angeles line is set to bring its line before buyers at Paris Fashion Week.

Agentry to Open New York Fashion Week: Men’s 2019-05-09 13:16:01The showcase on June 3 will include an inaugural All Stars Showcase.

CEO Talks: Bonobos’ Micky Onvural Takes Unique Marketing 2019-05-08 00:01:04Since becoming ceo last year, she has helped enhance the culture at the online retailer.

EXCLUSIVE: Randa Acquires Haggar Brand 2019-05-07 16:45:38The purchase brings the accessories manufacturer into the apparel business.

Bristol Studio Comes Into Its Own 2019-05-07 13:17:38The elevated men’s brand, centered around basketball culture, is forging a path for itself following some retooling of the business.

Pitti Uomo Brings Out the Big Guns for 2019-05-07 13:02:26While challenges are affecting the Italian fashion and textile industry, the Florentine trade show is gearing up to affirm its leading role in the men

Sterling Ruby: Pitti Uomo a ‘No Brainer’ to 2019-05-02 17:20:16The artist will present his label S.R. Studio. LA. CA in Florence next month.

Southern Tide, Reyn Spooner Partner on Capsule 2019-05-01 09:42:21The Hawaiian-themed shirt line is available beginning today.

Dior to Open Men’s Pop-ups Featuring Soroyama Robot 2019-05-01 08:16:58The first will be at CityCenterDC in Washington, followed by Holt Renfrew in Toronto and South Coast Plaza in Costa Mesa, Calif.

Penney’s Changes Chief Men’s Merchant 2019-04-24 16:36:50Jeff Useforge has replaced James Starke as head of the company's men's division.

J.Hilburn Adds Chief Marketing Officer 2019-04-24 11:20:17Casey Shilling will work to enhance the men's wear brand's omnichannel business.

Breaking Muscle

Fit to Fight Sleep Apnea 2019-05-09 13:30:39The reality is, 80 percent of people who have sleep apnea don’t know it. When we think about sleep apnea, we usually consider it a fat man&rsquo

Ditch the Rigid Meal Plan 2019-05-08 16:37:53Often, when people fall off their meal plan, not only do they feel like a failure they also have no idea what they should eat and then, all hell reall

10 Transformational Habits That Really Force a Change 2019-05-07 16:00:15The most sustainable, sensible, and successful lifestyle habits aren’t always sexy, but they work. Fads drive the fitness industry. Calorie coun

Fatigue: It's Just an Emotion 2019-05-06 16:06:22When it comes to fatigue during exercise, it’s all in your head.   read more

Eccentric Abdominal Training 2019-05-01 21:17:30Granted, abs are made in the kitchen, but they’re forged in the gym!   read more

Training the Trainer 2019-04-30 19:03:56Let your ego go, apologize when appropriate, and practice often.   So, you’ve passed your training certification. Congratulations.  

Women and Iron 2019-04-29 11:22:16Almost 50 percent of women and three-quarters of teenaged females aren’t getting enough iron from their food. Generally speaking, women are smal

Useful Shame: Countering Junk Food and Smartphone Addiction 2019-04-29 06:50:14Few influences have been as broadly destructive as unchecked smartphone culture and junk food eating habits. In a wave of evangelical fervor, the 18th

Effective Workouts You Can Do at Home 2019-04-27 19:27:34Ditch the I can’t get to the gym excuses, because there’s no place like home. Ditch the I can’t get to the gym excuses because there

You Should Be Taking Cold Showers 2019-04-25 20:51:03From rejuvenating your skin, reducing fats, to relaxing your mind, a cold shower has them all. You’re probably used to warm water when taking a

Muscle For Life

The Best Diets and Workouts for Your Body 2019-05-10 09:00:48Are you an ectomorph? Mesomorph? Endomorph? Does body type even matter? Listen to this podcast to find out. ..Read the full article on Muscle for Life

Muscle for Life Success: Alan C. 2019-05-10 09:00:25Alan lost 62 pounds in 6 months and got stronger on every lift following my Bigger Leaner Stronger program! ..Read the full article on Muscle for Life

The Best Bodyweight Workouts and Exercises You Can 2019-05-08 09:00:29If you want to use bodyweight workouts and exercises to “be your own gym” and gain muscle and strength without going to the gym, this arti

Dr. Spencer Nadolsky on How Not to Die 2019-05-08 09:00:07If you want to know how diet affects your risk of heart disease and what you can do to avoid it, you want to listen to this podcast. ..Read the full a

What’s New and Exciting in April? Legion Rebranding, 2019-05-06 07:00:54My team and I get asked often about what’s going on over here at Muscle for Life, so, here’s the latest and greatest as of April 2019. ..R

Muscle for Life Success: Bart C. 2019-05-03 09:00:35Bart gained 6.5 pounds of lean muscle in 10 months and got stronger on my Bigger Leaner Stronger program! ..Read the full article on Muscle for Life T

The Best Chest Workouts for Building Awesome Pecs 2019-05-01 09:00:29If you want strong, powerful, and defined pecs that pop, you want to do these chest exercises and workouts. ..Read the full article on Muscle for Life

Sal Di Stefano on Mastering the Mental Side 2019-05-01 09:00:20If you want to know how to deal with the mental hobgoblins that make it hard to eat properly, work out regularly, and deal with body image issues, you

What “They” Aren’t Telling You About Sugar Withdrawal 2019-04-29 09:00:40If you want to know the truth about sugar withdrawal, and what to do about it, then you want to listen to this podcast. ..Read the full article on Mus

Muscle For Life Success: Wayne F. 2019-04-26 09:00:43Wayne dropped 50 pounds in 12 months and added 170 pounds to his major lifts on my Bigger Leaner Stronger program! ..Read the full article on Muscle f

Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.